caret icon Back to all discussions

Robot assisted simple prostatectomy

Hi there,

Hs anyone had RASP? If so, what was your experience?

Thank you,

  1. Hi . I'm not personally familiar with RASP. Would the treatment be for prostate cancer or for benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH)? I ask because RASP is not considered a treatment for prostate cancer. The overview page from Brown University Health goes into more detail: https://www.brownhealth.org/centers-services/minimally-invasive-urology-institute/robot-assisted-prostatectomy. Hopefully anyone who has experience with this will chime in. Best, Richard (Team Member)

    1. Hi . I was unfamiliar with this, but did find this paper on the benefits of RASP before radiation for those with Prostate Cancer and Prostatomegaly: https://www.urotoday.com/conference-highlights/wcet-2024/154137-wcet-2024-robotic-simple-prostatectomy-followed-by-radiation-therapy-versus-robotic-radical-prostatectomy-propensity-matched-analysis-of-a-treatment-pathway-for-men-with-prostate-cancer-and-prostatomegaly.html.

      Concerning RASP v. HOLEP, I found these studies that had better results with RASP for the enlarged prostate: https://wjmh.org/DOIx.php?id=10.5534/wjmh.230054 and https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10357823/.

      I found one study on HOLEP and cancer treatment that concluded that "HoLEP is beneficial in debulking large prostate in PCa patients with bothersome LUTS on active surveillance or before radiotherapy. HoLEP reduces the contribution of large adenoma to PSA level, thus reflecting PSA level better and helping reduce overtreatment:" https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36463424/. Note that this was not comparing to RASP for the cancer treatment. I didn't find any direct comparisons for the cancer treatments. I hope this information is helpful and please feel free to keep us posted and to ask additional questions. Best, Richard (Team Member)

    2. thank you so much for these articles. My husband is scheduled for RASP on January 12th. These articles solidified his decision that RASP is the best plan of action for him. We are so grateful for this information you have shared with us.
      Thank you!!!

  2. I had the procedure last January and my PSA is still increasing..doubling in 8 months. I was told I should have asked to have a different procedure.

    1. I have more tests in January to determine the next course if treatment. We are hoping the numbers will stabilize and can be monitored only.

    2. I wish you the best. Please keep us posted as to how you are doing.

  3. Hi Guys,

    Can anyone shed light on this information:

    Case Request Operating Room:
    LAPAROSCOPY, SURGICAL PROSTATECTOMY, SIMPLE SUBTOTAL (INCLUDING CONTROL OF POSTOPERATIVE BLEEDING, VASECTOMY, MEATOTOMY, URETHRAL CALIBRATION AND/OR DILATION, AND INTERNAL
    URETHROTOMY), CYSTOLITHOTOMY,
    CYSTOTOMY WITH R... for Prostate cancer


    What does this all mean? I looked up the terminology, but still, what the heck?
    Why would vasectomy be mentioned? Unless it is something to be aware of during the surgery? Hubby had vasectomy 45 years ago. Is this common during prostate surgery?

    Thank you…

    1. Hi . Your concern is understandable. No doubt that there is the double edged sword of the fear of infection and the fear of sending him home with existing medical issues that could present a problem it the initial post-surgery period. I can tell you that my father-in-law (a prostate cancer survivor) recently had a similar scenario. He had a knee replacement, which is often done outpatient, but because of medical issues (previous AFib, blood pressure, and diabetes) they did decide to keep him for a night, but only after he and his wife asked. It also made a difference that my mother-in-law has medical issues that limit her caregiving abilities. It can't hurt to ask and lay out your concerns, including about your ability to help in an emergency. The worst that happens is that plans remain as they are now. Wishing you the best. Richard (Team Member)

    2. thank you again for your helpful and insightful reply. Since we are uncomfortable with the thought of immediate discharge, we will go ahead and pose the question to her. It doesn’t hurt to ask. Like you said, if she says no, then we will be prepared and can plan accordingly.

  4. Thank you, Richard. I’m sending the doctor a message today. I’ll post as soon as I hear back. Could be a day or two…

Please read our rules before posting.