ProstateCancer.net
caret icon Back to all discussions

New Guidelines for PSA Screening - What Are Your Thoughts?

The American Cancer Society just updated its screening guidelines for Prostate Cancer (see here for example: https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/12/health/new-prostate-cancer-screening-guideline-wellness and https://www.nbcnews.com/health/cancer/new-prostate-cancer-screening-guidelines-regular-psa-test-rcna608629).

It recommends increased PSA testing to every two years, starting from age 50 to 69 and those age 70 to 74 to discuss with the doctors. It also recommends starting screening at 45 for those at higher risk.

What do you think? Let us know.

  1. First of all, PSA is a poor indicator; that is the reason for the fear of unneeded treatment and tepid support for screening. PSA testing should be replaced with imaging.

    They are still looking at numbers and not patients' symptoms. We have men in their 40s with Stage 4 cancer which indicates they should have been screened earlier. They lose out because they don't fall into the statistical norm.

    They are still using PSA thresholds and though they've changed the threshold levels the thresholds are still irrelevant. There is no scientific basis for using PSA level to decide which group to screen. As an example, as did President Biden's PCP, my PCP stopped screening me at age 70. I had a PSA of 2.8 ng/ml so did not meet the 4 ng/ml panic threshold for men over age 70.

    I also had Stage 2b prostate cancer. Being an statistical outlier, I was taken off screening.

    The ten year life expectancy is also playing games with men's lifes. The doctors are not looking at the patient's likely life span based on the patient's family history, but rather on statistics based on the family histories of other men. My family typically lives to the mid 90s which means I can expect my expiration date in about 15 years, so I would not be screened or treated now under these guidelines. I have not had PSA tests since age 70 so I have had time to develop cancer that has not been diagnosed and could well go to metastisis before death.

    Too, I don't see conversations going on between doctor and patient about these decisions. I feel probably a majority of treatment is done without truly informed consent.

    Guy B. Meredith, "cured" prostate cancer survivor

    1. Hi . You are hitting on one of my major issues on the upper end. Cutting off screening at a certain age is a little bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy - it is artificially lowering life expectancy by not treating men for something largely treatable. Also, as you rightfully point out, it takes the individual circumstances and overall health out of the equation.
      You mentioned imaging as a more reliable way of screening. I would add that various urinary biomarker tests could be used as additional tools. The technology is there and I struggle to understand why it is underutilized. From a cost perspective it would seem to better than treating later stage cancers. Best, Richard (Team Member)

Please read our rules before posting.